Purina Pro Plan vs Purina One Cat and Dog Food Comparison 2019

Purina Pro Plan vs Purina

Dogs and cats do not always agree on the same things but one thing they both have a thing for is good food.

If you are one of those pet owners who believe in giving their pets the very best then you are no stranger to the Purina dog food brand.

The Purina pet food brand has over 80 years worth of experience providing nourishment to dogs and cats of all ages with its all natural food blend infused with great flavors and remains a top choice for even the pickiest of pets. Would you like to know more?  

Purina Pro plan and Purina One pet foods are two of a kind but unique in their own way with a wide variety of flavors to give your pet a treat.

Both brands are often singled out as one of the best pet foods because of their nutritional value as well as affordability. So what’s do they contain?

We have taken the liberty to provide you with all the information you will need about the Purina Pro Plan and Purina One; everything from guaranteed analysis, history, price information, product safety, and others. So are you ready? Let’s begin.

Purina Pro Plan vs Purina One FAQ

What is guaranteed analysis?

The concept of guaranteed analysis on pet food products is to assure purchasers of the precise nutrient content of each consumable. Emphasized by AAFCO, guaranteed analysis by food labels must meet certain requirements such as an exact value for the minimum percentage of crude protein and fat, as well as the maximum percentages of crude fiber and moisture on the basis of dry matter obtained. All of the percentages that I use in this comparison are averages of dry matter basis. Learn about dry matter basis here.

Which one has more protein?

The difference in protein content between both brands is not so significant. Purina pro plan leads in protein content by 2% for wet dog food and 5.1% for dry cat food while Purina One takes a 4.4% lead in wet cat food.

Which is Cheaper?

Purina Pro Plan is more expensive than Purina One

Which one has more flavors?

Purina pro Plan dominates with a wider variety of flavor than Purina One on all recipe types but for dog treats

Which one has more recalls?

Both brands have had recalls at least once.

Purina Pro Plan and Purina One Pros and Cons

Purina Pro Plan Pros:

Purina Pro Plan Cons:

Purina One Pros:

Purina One Cons:


Type Of Pet Foods From Purina Pro Plan and Purina One

Food Type Purina Pro Plan Purina One
 Dry Cat Food 42 recipes 14 recipes
Wet Cat food 29 recipes 15 recipes
Cat Treats 2 treats 3 treats
Dry Dog food 22 recipes 11 recipes
Wet Dog Food 66 recipes 12 recipes
Dog Treats 4 treats
Total 162 types 55 types

Purina Pro Plan has a few more recipes up its sleeves than Purina One for both wet and dry pet foods as well as treats.

Purina Pro Plan vs Purina One Dog and Cat food

Dog and Cat Food Nutritional Value

There is much emphasis on nutritional value and the importance of making these values known.

The AAFCO stipulated that all pet food brands must adhere to the law by providing a guaranteed analysis report stating all nutritional content in their proportions for every pet food product.

This will enable buyers to weigh ingredients, compare, flavors, and decide which brand is best suited to their pets. The table below shows the nutritional content (Potein, Fiber, Fat) of Purina Pro plan and Purina One.

Percentages are calculated on the basis of dry matter content.

Dry dog food Purina Pro Plan Purina One
Protein 31.8% 31.6%
Fat 17.9% 17.2%
Fiber 4.3% 4.3%
     
Wet Dog Food Purina Pro Plan Purina One
Protein 47.3% 45.3%
Fat 16.4% 25.8%
Fiber 7.2% 7.1%

Dogs are extremely energetic and can burn a lot of calories per day on just horsing around. There is a need for dogs to replenish after a hard day’s play.

Protein is probably the most essential component of a dog’s diet. Without adequate protein dogs may begin to develop numerous health problems.

Both brands however, provide adequate protein content with very little difference in proportion. Purina pro plan takes a narrow lead in protein content.

Fat in your pets diet can save you from a ton of unnecessary trips to the Vet. Both brands provide substantial amounts of fat diet. Purina One leads by 9.42% on fat content for wet dog food?

Do cats need these nutrients as well? Let’s see what the cat food contains.   

Dry Cat food Purina Pro Plan Purina One
Protein 45.6% 40.5%
Fat 17.4% 14.5%
Fiber 3.6% 3.6%
     
Wet Cat Food Purina Pro Plan Purina One
Protein 47.3% 55.9%
Fat 16.4% 14.7%
Fiber 7.2% 7.4%

Cats are Carnivores, and therefore probably require as much, if not more protein than dogs. This is evident in the report.

While Purina pro plan leads by 5.10% in dry food protein, Purina One dominates in protein with an 8.6% difference on wet cat food.

Fat and fiber difference in content are not so much.

Fiber is just as important in pet diet as any other nutrient as it mitigates digestive issues in the stomach especially during diet formula transitions which can often be problematic.

Dog and Cat Food Price Comparison

A reasonable amount goes into the feeding of our furry friends. It is very important that we provide them with the best diets and at the same time, it would also be an added advantage if we could get the best value at the most affordable rates.

This is where price comparisons become somewhat necessary. Let’s take a look at the Purina Pro Plan and Purina one price differences to see which one would crack the piggy bank more.

Dry Dog Food Purina Pro Plan Purina One
Per Pound $2.01 $1.41
Per Calorie $0.0011 $0.0008
Wet Dog Food    
Per Pound $2.84 $1.67
Per Calorie $0.0063 $0.0033
Dry Cat Food Purina Pro Plan Purina One
Per Pound $2.90 $1.72
Per Calorie $0.0016 $0.0010
Wet Cat Food    
Per Pound $4.94 $5.00
Per Calorie $0.0116 $0.0117

What is the actual difference between cost per pound (lb) and cost per calorie (kcal)? Simple, cost per pound is inclusive of moisture content which holds no actual value while cost per calorie provides price on dry matter alone. Therefore, the cost per calorie (kcal) is a more accurate metric.

What flavors are available for Dog and Cat food?

Purina Pro Plan

The pro plan has made major improvements on its most controversial ingredients and has come out with exceptional new flavors with no corn, no soy , no wheat, no artificial colorings or flavors, no poultry by-products and especially no preservatives.

So what does the new improved Purina Pro Plan have? Major flavors for Purina Pro Plan include shredded turkey and chicken, turkey and sweet potatoes, chicken and egg, turkey and barley, beef and peas, beef and salmon, and a wide variety of others.

Purina One

Purina One has a targeted formula that caters to pets of all life stage and is suitable for pets with special nutritional needs.

Ingredients include high-protein meat, fish, and poultry such as chicken, turkey, beef, lamb, and other protein sources. Purina One is rick in omega fatty acids, fat soluble vitamins and minerals for a healthy skin and stronger immune system.

About the Purina Pro Plan and Purina One

Purina Brand Information

Purina is a company built and inspired by the love for pets and guided by the strong belief that every pet has the right to a longer life which is greatly affected by the quality of their food. For more than 90 years, Purina has invested greatly on innovations and manufacturing of peculiar pet food products which has culminated to various Purina Brands such as Purina Pro Plan, Purina One, and a significant others.

Every formula has a distinct feature, from hypoallergenic canine formulas to probiotics and antioxidant supplements.

Product Safety and Recalls through History

Companies make scheduled recalls on products that may have a foreseen defect or safety issues. The importance of a recall is to conduct further safety tests in order to effect changes to product to ensure that it is safe for use.

Purina Pro Plan Recalls

  • Recalled once: March 9, 2016 for incorrect report on Vitamins and minerals content

Purina One Recalls

  • Recalled once: Aug 30, 2013 for salmonella

Purina Pro Plan Vs Purina One: And the winner goes to…

It has been a very close one with both brands putting out their best qualities.

The Purina Pro plan has a higher advantage when it comes to protein content and a wider variety of flavors while Purina Pro makes it up with affordability.

Both brands have had one safety recall each. This leads us to a conclusion in favor of Purina Pro Plan; however, both brands are top pet food brands and are highly recommended for pets of all ages.

References:

https://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/dog-food-reviews/purina-one-dog-food-dry/

https://www.proplan.com/dogs/compare

https://www.purinaone.com/

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *