American Journey vs Taste of the wild Su-purr Comparison 2024

American Journey vs Taste of the wild
American Journey vs Taste of the wild

Do you want to be at peace knowing your pets are nutritionally well taken care of by your pet food brand of choice?

If YES, then you should definitely consider feeding your pets with either Taste of the Wild or Nutro pet foods. Whether your dogs and cats have finicky appetites or they are heavy eaters, these popular brands have got you covered.

They provide the most nutritious delicacies formulated with top-notch ingredients which your pets will find irresistible and thus they are highly recommended by both vets and pet owners. To help you make an informed choice on one of these brands for your pet, let’s closely look at what they offer and how it confers to your pets’ requirements and your budget.

Also keep in mind that during the course of this article we will show you precisely what to look out for when purchasing pet food for your furry friend.  

After you are done with this awesome comparison check out American journey and Taste of the wild here to see the different flavors and pricing.


🤔 American Journey vs Taste of the wild FAQ

What is guaranteed analysis?

The concept of guaranteed analysis on pet food products is to assure purchasers of the precise nutrient content of each consumable. Emphasized by AAFCO, guaranteed analysis by food labels must meet certain requirements such as an exact value for the minimum percentage of crude protein and fat, as well as the maximum percentages of crude fiber and moisture on the basis of dry matter obtained. All of the percentages that I use in this comparison are averages of dry matter basis. Learn about dry matter basis here.
Which one has more protein?

Taste of the Wild has more protein for dry and wet dog foods than the American Journey brand while the American Journey brand has more protein than Taste of the Wild for dry and wet cat foods.

Which one is cheaper?

The American Journey brand provides cheaper dry and wet dog foods while the Taste of the Wild offers cheaper dry and wet cat foods.

Which one has more flavor?

The American journey offers 57 different flavors while the Taste of the Wild offers only 18 flavors.

Which one has received more recalls?

While the Taste of the Wild has only been recalled once, the American Journey has never been recalled.

Check out the current prices, recipes and flavors for American Journey and Taste of the wild

⚖️ American Journey and Taste of the wild Pros and Cons

American Journey Pros:

American Journey Cons:

Taste of the wild Pros:

Taste of the wild Cons:

😻 Types Of Pet Food

Product (Dog Food)American JourneyTaste of the Wild
Dry Food25 recipes9 recipes
Wet Food7 recipes5 recipes
Treats8 recipes
Product (Cat Food)  
Dry Food4 recipes2 recipes
Wet Food13 recipes2 recipes
😻 See all American Journey recipes 😻 See all Taste of the wild recipes

The number of flavors offered by Taste of the Wild gives American journey an upper advantage especially for dogs and cats who are picky, hence, the American Journey would be a better option in this case as it offers 39 flavors more than the Taste of the Wild brand.

🥕 Nutritional Value Comparison

The nutritional health of our pets depends on our choices to provide a complete and balanced diet for them which must contain all the key nutrients and essential supplements as prescribed.

Our pets need meals that will not only provide energy to their bodies but also gratify all their metabolic demands.

To ensure all these nutritional requirements are met by your pet food of choice, carefully scrutinize the detailed information of the types of nutrient offered in the recipes such as protein, fats and fibre, their minimum and maximum concentrations, feeding schedule, ingredients and others printed on the food wrap as obligated by the AAFCO.

Let us do a quick comparison of the nutritional offers the American Journey vs the Taste of the Wild

American JourneyProtein(dry)Protein(wet)Fat (dry)Fat(wet)Fiber (dry) Fiber (wet)
Taste of the Wild       
🥕 See more American Journey info 🥕 See more Taste of the wild info


This macronutrient is a major source of essential amino which serves as an energy source as well as a metabolic tool in dogs and cats.

While dogs need ten essential amino acids from protein consumption, cats need the same plus taurine and cats require twice the amount of protein needed by dogs.

The amount and types of protein required by these pets are dependent on their species, age and active level. It is also important to know that the value of a protein source is dependent on the types and number of amino acids it is composed of.


This is the energy storehouse of cats and most dogs. Fatty acids from fats absorbs, stores and transports with ease all the fat soluble vitamins contained in a balance and complete pet meal.

They are also important in stabilizing antioxidants or preservatives present in dry foods, regulating body temperature, preserving and protecting internal organs and other important structural and developmental functions.

Note that coconut oil, though considered an essential oil, does not provide any essential amino acid and could be harmful to the health of pets.

The American Journey dry foods have more fats while the Taste of the Wild wet foods has more fats.


The fibre content of American Journey’s dog and cat foods seems a bit higher than that of Taste of the Wild with an exception of wet cat foods.

Fibre, also known as roughage, is that portion of fruit and vegetable in our pet’s meal that is almost indigestible.

They function in the increased transit time of pet’s intestine, adsorption of body fluid, recovery of cells in the colon after injury, annihilate excessive growth of harmful microorganisms like bacteria and others.  


As important as water is to humans and plants so is it to animals especially companion animals. Every dog and cat must have easy access to clean drinking water else the money spent on exotic meals becomes useless.

If a dog or cat experiences 10% water loss, it could result in serious health issues and when the loss goes beyond 15%, death could result.

💰 Price Comparison

Comparing the prices of products seem easy doesn’t it? I mean, just look at the price tag right? this is true in many cases, however for pet foods there is a different way to check the value of your pet food of choice.

Do you have any idea of how to compare the cost of your favorite pet food with another? Have you ever seen these parameters; cost/kcal and cost/lb on the pet food bag and you are wondering what they indicate?

Well, pet food prices are always valued in either cost per calories (Kcal) which is for the dry matter only or the cost per pound (lb) which includes both dry matter and moisture.

This article recommends the cost per calorie metric but for the sake of pet owners who still uses the cost per pound metric, we would be comparing the costs of both brands using both metrics.

Dog FoodA J(dry)A J (wet)TOTW (dry)TOTW (wet)
Per pound$1.66$2.31$1.86$2.79
Per calorie$0.0011$0.0044$0.0011$0.0060
Cat FoodA J (dry)A J (wet)TOTW (dry)TOTW (wet)
Per pound$2.38$4.36$2.29$4.26
Per Calorie$0.0014$0.0099$0.0013$0.0100
💰 See more American Journey info 💰 See more Taste of the wild info

So where is the best place to purchase these brands? Good question! Overall, has the cheapest prices.

They also offer 30% on your first autoship order which saves you a good chunk of change and makes your pet food ordering process automatic. Overall, this has saved me a ton of time.

🤤 Ingredients and Flavors

As far as flavors go, pet foods manufacturers often use digests. These are materials that produce concentrated forms of natural flavors when processed with either acids, heat or enzymes.

With this kind of technique, manufacturers tend to reduce their production cost as only a small amount is needed to compound the digest required for a desired flavor yet some brands still use sufficient amounts of organic ingredients required to produce their desired flavors.

American Journey

To achieve the different flavors of the 57 recipes American Journey is known for, they use premium quality brown rice, deboned salmon and turkey, chicken and chicken meal, sweet potato, dried beet pulp, garbonzo beans, menhaden fish meal, salmon oil, rosemary extract, chicken fat, folic acid, mixed tocopherols, dried kelp, carrots, and others.

American Journey uses two main controversial ingredients, pea protein and tomato pomace but they are neither harmful neither have they resulted in any recalls.

Popular Flavors

  • Beef and sweet potato
  • Soft baked dog treats

Taste of the wild

Taste of the wild does not offer as many recipes and flavors as American Journey yet the quality of ingredients used by this brand is not what you find in the average brand. It is one of the “expensive” pet foods.

Some commonly used ingredients of the brand are lamb meal, salmon oil, blueberries, beef, flaxseed, wild boar, ocean fish meal, egg product, canola oil, pea flour, chicory root, chelated minerals and others.

Brewer’s yeast and tomato pomace which are by-products beer and tomato processing are the only controversial ingredient associated with this brand.

Popular flavors

  • Lamb in Gravy
  • Grain-free Roasted Venison and Smoked Salmon

Check out the current American Journey recipes and Taste of the wild recipes here

🏡 About American Journey and Taste of the wild

American journey Information

The American Journey brand is owned and distributed by Chewy Inc. It was founded by Ryan Cohen and Michael Day and presently being manufactured by its Kansas based production facility. The company sources its ingredients from within and outside the United State.

Some of the recipes presently in the market include the lamb and sweet potato recipe for puppies, chicken and turkey recipes, minced turkey recipes, salmon and brown rice recipes, beef and vegetable stew recipe and others.

Taste of the wild Information

This pet food brand manufactures dog and cat foods in Central and Northern California, Missouri and Sothern Carolina. These are the manufacturing plants are all owned by Diamond Pet Company which produces the brand’s products, however, Schell and Kampeter Inc. was and still is the owner of the brand.

Some of the popular recipes of the brand are Appalachian Valley recipe, Pine Forest Canine, Pacific Stream Canine recipe and others. Two of the nine dry dog food manufactured by Taste of the Wild brand is dedicated to growing and small dogs.

🙀 Product Safety and Recalls through History

Companies make scheduled recalls on products that may have a foreseen defect or safety issues. The importance of a recall is to conduct further safety tests in order to effect changes to product to ensure that it is safe for use.

American Journey Recalls

No recall

Taste of the wild Recalls

  • May 5, 2012: Presence of Salmonella sp

🏆 American Journey Vs Taste of the wild: And the winner goes to…

American Journey is the brand of choice when compared with the Taste of the Wild because it has proven to be exceptional on the basis of safety, number of flavors, ingredients cocktails, price and amount of key nutrients.

If you want Then you should choose
Higher levels of protein Both brands
A cost effective option American Journey
A wider variety of flavors and ingredients American Journey
Safety, based on number of recalls American Journey
A balanced diet for all age levels Both brands


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top