Blue Wilderness vs Blue Buffalo: The Ulti-mutt Comparison 2024

Blue Wilderness vs Blue Buffalo

Are you conversant with pet food brands? Then you may have heard of Blue Wilderness and Blue Buffalo.

In this article, we will explore and analyze the nitty-gritty of the popular Blue Buffalo pet food brand and the meticulously packaged Blue Wilderness pet food products using up-to-date nutritional and price information.

All your throbbing questions on pet food quality as well as fundamentals will be covered in this article. You will have access to ingredient quality, product safety, costing, recall history, pros and cons of your desired pet food among other qualities.

After you are done with this awesome comparison check out Blue Buffalo and Blue Wilderness here to see the different flavors and pricing.


🤔Blue Buffalo vs Blue Wilderness FAQ

What is guaranteed analysis?

The concept of guaranteed analysis on pet food products is to assure purchasers of the precise nutrient content of each consumable. Emphasized by AAFCO, guaranteed analysis by food labels must meet certain requirements such as an exact value for the minimum percentage of crude protein and fat, as well as the maximum percentages of crude fiber and moisture on the basis of dry matter obtained. All of the percentages that I use in this comparison are averages of dry matter basis. Learn about dry matter basis here.
Which one has more protein?

Blue Buffalo offers more protein in the wet/canned pet foods whereas Blue Wilderness offers more proteins in the dry foods.

Which one is cheaper?

The Blue Wilderness pet food is slightly cheaper across all meal type when compared with Blue Buffalo, while Blue Buffalo is still quite affordable.

Which one has more flavor?

Blue Buffalo has more flavours than Blue Wilderness, whereas Blue Wilderness offer the best kinds of flavors.

Which one has had more recalls?

Blue Buffalo has been recalled nine times while Blue Wilderness has just two recalls. Some brands recalled their products by themselves for the safety of the pets nevertheless, Blue Buffalo has more recalls.

Check out the current prices, recipes and flavors for Blue Buffalo and Blue Wilderness.

⚖️Blue Buffalo and Blue Wilderness Pros and Cons

Blue Buffalo Pros:

Blue Buffalo Cons:

Blue Wilderness Pros:

Blue Wilderness Cons:

😻 Types Of Pet Food From Blue Buffalo and Blue Wilderness

ProductBlue WildernessBlue Buffalo
Dry Dog Food27 Recipes85 Recipes
Wet Dog Food34 Recipes103 Recipes
Dog Treats50 Treats
Dry Cat Food14 Recipes40 Recipes
Wet Cat Food34 Recipes48 Recipes
Cat Treats15 Treats
😻 See all Blue wilderness recipes😻 See all Blue Buffalo recipes

As shown on the table, The Blue Buffalo brand has 85 dry foods recipes, 103 wet dog foods recipes offering 50 dog treats while Blue Wilderness with 27 recipes for dry food, 34 wet foods recipe.

For the fluffy feline creatures, the Blue Buffalo brand offers 40 recipes for dry cat food, 48 recipes for wet cat foods and 15 cats treat.

Blue Wilderness offers 14 recipes for dry cat food, 34 recipes for wet cat foods and no cat treat obviously giving Blue Buffalo the higher advantage as the most flavored brand

🥕Blue Buffalo vs Blue Wilderness Nutritional Value Comparison

Food types are mainly categorized using the nutritional values offered in them. Certain nutrients are required in high quantity, while others are only required in small quantities or even as micro-nutrients.

Our pets have delicate biological systems that most times require a reasonably balanced diet in order to grow, develop, and maintain a fairly constant internal environment; immune to diseases and other health problems. For a jovial, healthy and growing pet, you have to pay keen attention to your pets’ nutritional requirements.

Most pets of same species and breed usually have same or similar nutritional requirements but most pets have peculiar needs as their systems function differently due to varying environmental factors, such as lifestyle, genealogy, etc.

The nutritional values of all pet foods ever manufactured are presented in form of a guaranteed analysis which can be found on the label of the food products as enforced by the Association of American Feed Control Officials(AAFCO).

The analysis of the pet food usually is required to provide guaranteed percentages of nutrients present such as crude protein and crude fat, as well as the maximum percentages of crude fibre and water content.

Product (Dry Dog food)Blue Wilderness Blue Buffalo
Crude Protein31%28.5%
Crude Fat15.2%15.0%
Crude Fiber6.0%7.1%
Product (Wet Dog food)  
Crude Protein43%40.3%
Crude Fat33%25.0%
Crude Fiber6.5%7.6%
Product (Dry Cat food)Blue Wilderness Blue Buffalo
Crude Protein36.1%37.0%
Crude Fat16.5%16.3%
Crude Fiber5.2%6.4%
Product (Wet Cat food)  
Crude Protein40.5%45.2%
Crude Fat28.0%24.3%
Crude Fiber6.7%8.3%
🥕 See more Blue Wilderness info🥕 See more Blue Buffalo Info


Protein content is a vital part of pet food nutrition that basically stands as the primary component of all pet food meals. pets, especially cats have an affinity for protein meals. protein is solely responsibly for the building of muscular tissues due to the build-up of amino acids which form peptide bonds to form protein.

The importance of protein in pet food diet cannot be undermined. Many pet food brands use protein as the main ingredient in every dog or cat food.

Also, there is a stipulation of protein content margin by the AAFCO which enforces the need for minimum and maximum percentages of protein. These percentages are used to indicate appropriate levels of protein for pet development as well as excess or inadequate levels.

while comparing pet food brands, one is required to take a look at the levels of protein for both brands to know which amount is suitable for their pet breed and size as well.

Fat Content

one popular question when it comes to pet food has always been “is fat necessary for pets?” well, the answer is yes! of course this trumps all ideas of how fat is unhealthy and causes heath problems such as obesity in humans, however, pets are totally different. it is a common knowledge that most balanced diet, if not all, must contain fat. However, fat is a significant component in all pet food and must at least account for 10% of the total meal.

why do pets need fat? From a plethora of reasons why pets require fat for their daily nutritional need we could focus on certain physicals specifics such as energy, controls the unnecessary loss of water in the body, and it speeds up the rate of vitamin absorption in the body, this is because vitamins are soluble in fat.

Fat furnishes your pet with a shiny skin and well maintained coat. This automatically suggests that when your pet has a dull skin or fur coat they may be lacking enough fat to absorb vitamins.

it is needless to add that fat is tasty and improves the flavor of every pet food meal.

Fiber Content

Why is fiber so important in pet meals? I mean, they are not particularly the tastiest of all food ingredients so what are their functions. let’s look at it this way; our pets, especially dog, love to chew on every thing in sight. some meals can be quite palatable for them while some may not blend so well with their digestive system. Most pets usually experience series of digestive system issues very often and this can be avoided with fiber.

what does fiber do? It is a food component that assists with digestion especially in the small intestine. Fiber assists in the breakdown of food particles before they are moved into the large intestine for further processing. It can be said that the gut and fiber have somewhat of a symbiotic relationship which also includes the maintenance of a fairly optimum level of good bacteria in the gut. So yes, fiber is also one of the components that one should look out for on guaranteed analysis.

Water (Moisture)

Water is a source of life and it is no news that water plays a key role in the proper functioning of the body for many reasons. However, can one really classify water as a nutrient? for many reasons, yes. This is because most meals are made with water and are incomplete without water. another major part is that your pet’s system is composed mainly of water. This means that there is a certain amount of bodily fluid that must be maintained by re-hydrating as often as necessary

So what does water composition don for your pet? whether your pet eats dry meals or wet meals there is usually a bowl of water waiting to be ingested. so what does water do for your pet’s system?

Water improves bodily functions such as speeding up metabolic processes, elimination of waste and byproducts from the body, transportation of nutrients, multivitamins, minerals and other components in the body, regulation of body temperature as well as other functions.

water deficiency can lead to dehydration, indigestion, increased body temperature, emaciation, and many other problems.

💰 Price Comparison

Even though Blue Buffalo and Blue wilderness have a lot in common their prices may differ.

💰See the best Blue wilderness and Blue Buffalo prices

So where is the best place to purchase these brands? Good question! Overall, has the cheapest prices.

They also offer free shipping for orders above $25 which saves you a good chunk of change and makes your pet food ordering process automatic. Overall, this has saved me a ton of time.

🤤 Ingredients and Flavors

Blue Wilderness

Blue Wilderness combines variety of ingredients which are mixed and matched to produce unique flavours, they include: Chicken, chicken meal, chicken fat, fish meal, lamb sweet potatoes, pea, cinnamon broccoli, cranberries, carrot, blueberries, peas, apples, barley, beef, beta-Carotene, brown rice, canola oil, chicken fat, chicken liver and more.

Popular flavors

  • Chicken and trout flaked entree
  • soft-moist chicken and salmon recipe
  • chicken and turkey

Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo prides in combining several natural ingredients to produce their formulas. Some include: Deboned Chicken, chicken meal, fish meal, sweet potatoes, pea, cranberries, carrot, blueberries, peas, Tapioca starch, flaxseed, Dehydrated Alfalfa meals, Dried Egg products, Dried Tomato pomace and more vitamins and minerals.

Popular Flavors

  • chicken entree
  • Salmon Entree
  • chicken, Lamb, and beef
  • Duck and potato

Check out the current Blue wilderness and Blue Buffalo recipes here

🏡 About Blue Buffalo and Blue Wilderness

Blue Buffalo Information

Blue Buffalo is one of the numerous pet food brand that has made major impact in the pet food market. firstly because of it wide variety of flavors and also because of its impact on pets as one of the most loved pet food by most house pets. The history of this brand started in 2002 as a family business.

A dedicated pet lover Bill Bishop decided to embark on a quest to produce the best pet food brand suited for all pets, especially those going through some form of health challenge. The intent was spawned from the illness of the family pet called “BLUE”. The pet was diagnosed with cancer and had very little time too leave.

With the help of a professional nutritionist and a veterinarian, the founder and his sons were able to manufacture one of the best pet food brands of all time.

Blue Wilderness Information

Blue Wilderness is only a branch of the Blue Buffalo brand with major reference and inspiration from the ancestral pets who were mostly of wolf breeds. The Blue wilderness, as its name portrays is a blend of feral rich flavors and a grain free meal that provides all the necessary ingredients needed by your pet to survive.

The Brand is known for its Life Source Bits which contains vitamins and minerals as well as antioxidants which gives your pet a healthy alternative and a wider variety under the blue pet food brand umbrella.

🙀 Product Safety and Recalls through History

Companies make scheduled recalls on products that may have a foreseen defect or safety issues. The importance of a recall is to conduct further safety tests in order to effect changes to product to ensure that it is safe for use.

Blue Wilderness Recalls

This brand has only been recalled twice.

  • Jan. 31st, 2019 – Elevated levels of Vitamin D
  • March, 20th, 2017 – Elevated levels of naturally-occurring beef thyroid hormones

Blue Buffalo Recalls

This brand has been recalled nine times.

  • Nov. 25th, 2015 – Salmonella
  • Nov. 6th, 2015 – Presence of Propylene Glycol
  • May 31st, 2016 – Mold
  • March 18th, 2017 – elevated beef thyroid hormone
  • Feb. 14th, 2017 – presence of aluminum
  • March 3rd, 2017 – Foil Seal Packaging Problem
  • Oct. 8th, 2010 – toxic levels of vitamin D
  • April 19th, 2007 – Melamine
  • April 26th, 2007 – Melamine

🏆Blue Buffalo Vs Blue Wilderness: And the winner goes to…

It has been a tough call for both brands seeing that Blue Wilderness leads in the Dog Category and Blue Buffalo taking the lead in the Feline category.

There is no winner for me as the choice is dependent on the breed you have although they are both rich in protein content, fiber and fat content, Blue Wilderness still stands out as the cheaper brand.

Blue Buffalo obviously has a lot more flavors for both dog and cat foods although with more recalls than Blue Wilderness which offers less flavors.

However, both are great brands and offer great nutritional values for pets.

If you want Then you should choose
Higher levels of protein Both
A cost effective option Blue Wilderness
A wider variety of flavors and ingredients Blue buffalo
Safety, based on number of recalls Blue Wilderness
A balanced diet for all age levels both


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top