Fromm vs Acana: The Purr-fect pet food comparison for 2019

Acana vs Fromm

It can be frustrating and somewhat disappointing when your fluffy friend continually rejects the pet food brand that he or she had been fed with for a period of time.

It is even more damning when they react badly to something they ate.

In this article, we will discuss two brands, Fromm and Acana extensively. By the end you will know exactly which one is right for you furry little friend!

After you are done with this awesome comparison, check out Acana and Fromm here to see the different flavors and pricing.

Contents:

The total health and immunity of your pets to diseases largely depends on the food they consume so it is important to be guided when shopping for pet food.

The perk of purchasing popular pet foods is that you never have to worry if your pet is eating right or getting enough nutrients or if the diet is balanced enough because every pet food brand has a standard and a minimum and maximum nutritional requirement which is regulated by the AAFCO.

This means that every pet food has been analysed and vetted by the regulatory body.

Each product contains exactly enough nutrients for your pets daily sustenance as well as physical and mental development.

So whether you own an energetic Golden retriever or an American Bobtail, you are sure that your pet food of choice provides more than enough for them to survive.

We would review their brand history, nutritional components, ingredient quality, pricing, pros and cons and every other thing you need to know.

🤔 Acana vs Fromm FAQ

What is guaranteed analysis?

The concept of guaranteed analysis on pet food products is to assure purchasers of the precise nutrient content of each consumable. Emphasized by AAFCO, guaranteed analysis by food labels must meet certain requirements such as an exact value for the minimum percentage of crude protein and fat, as well as the maximum percentages of crude fiber and moisture on the basis of dry matter obtained. All of the percentages that I use in this comparison are averages of dry matter basis. Learn about dry matter basis here.

Which one has more protein?

Acana takes the lead as it provides more protein than Fromm. whereas the difference is not alarming but it is notable. For the dry dog food category, Acana provides up to 7.14 percent more protein than Fromm food products. The result is the same in the cat food category. Acana food products is more protein-rich by 2.50 percent.

Which is cheaper?

Acana costs slightly higher than Fromm food products. While the price difference between these two brands is not very significant, it may be of importance when purchasing in large quantities.

Which of the products has more flavors?

Fromm takes the lead in this category as it has almost double the number of flavours owned by Acana. While Acana has 49 flavours, Fromm has 84 flavours.

Which one has had more recalls?

Fromm has been recalled once whereas Acana has never been recalled.

Check the current prices and recipes/flavors for Acana and Fromm.

⚖️ Acana and Fromm Pros and Cons

Fromm Pros:

Fromm Cons:

Acana Pros:

Acana Cons:

😻 Types Of Pet Food

ProductFrommAcana
Dry Dog Food29 Recipes37 Recipes
Wet Dog Food21 Recipes❌
Dog Treats10 Treats4 Treats
Dry Cat Food12 Recipes8 Recipes
Wet Cat Food12 Recipes❌
Cat Treats❌❌
😻 See All Fromm recipes😻 See All Acana recipes

As presented on the table, Fromm has a wider variety than Acana; the difference in the number of flavors is very significant. Acana is more focused on natural food so they do not produce wet meals. As shown on the table, both brands do not have cat treats.

🥕 Nutritional Value Comparison

One of the most important factors to consider when getting acquainted with a brand is its nutritional value.

You need to be able to answer the question, “how much value does this food type have when nutrients are being considered?”

If a food brand performs poorly in this regard, you can conclude that it is not good for your pet.

AAFCO has summed up the most essential nutrients into protein, fat, and fiber.

You must check food labels to see the proportions that each brand provides. The table below provides this information for Fromm and Acana.

Dry Dog FoodFrommAcana
Crude Protein28.7%35.9%
Crude Fat16.6%18.8%
Crude Fiber6.6%6.5%
Dry Cat FoodFrommAcana
Crude Protein37.5%40%
Crude Fat19.2%22.2%
Crude Fiber5.3%3.9%
🥕 See more Fromm info 🥕 See more Acana info

As presented on the table above, Acana has better nutritional components than Fromm in all categories except fiber.

For the dry dog food, it is only higher by an infinitesimal 0.1 percent. Fromm is also higher by about 1.4 percent in the cat food category.

It is important to know the functions that these nutrients perform in our pet’s body. That way, we can appreciate the nutrients while shopping.

Protein

A balanced canine and feline diet can never be short of protein. Your pets need protein to function optimally. Not only does it repair worn-out tissues, it helps build the body.

Cats and dogs need essential amino acids, those that the body cannot provide independently.

These nutrients are supplied by protein-rich meals. Protein is an indispensable nutrient.

Fat

You will never need to worry about the look, taste and feel of your pet food if it contains fat.

Apart from the fact that it makes food appealing to the taste bud, it helps the body absorb fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, E, and K)

Fat provides more energy than carbohydrates and protein. It is an essential component of a balanced diet.

Consumption of fats should be supervised as it can have adverse effects when taken excessively.

Fiber

Food must be well digested so that the body can absorb all the nutrients into the bloodstream, fiber makes this happen.

With fiber, you do not need to worry about colon or gut health, digestion, weight gain or constipation.  

💰 Price Comparison

Cost is one of the most important components of product knowledge. Good products are admirable and desirable but the timeless question is, “can you afford it?”

Understanding pet food price can be confusing. You can either buy on a “per pound” basis or on a “per calorie” basis.

These metrics give different results depending on your shopping habits. The best yardstick for the average buyer is “per kcalorie (Kcal)” because food product is weighed without the moisture content.

The table below shows the cost of Fromm and Acana food product

Dry Dog FoodFrommAcana
Per Pound$2.37 $2.96
Per Calorie$0.00014 $0.00019
Dry Cat FoodFrommAcana
Per Pound$3.75 $4.62
Per Calorie$0.00020 $0.00025
💰 See the best Fromm prices💰 See the best Acana prices

The table clearly shows that Acana is the more expensive brand as it costs slightly more when both metrics are applied.

🤤 Ingredients and Flavors

Fromm

Of most brands, Fromm has the most flavours, they comprise of the following ingredients:

real meat and fish, duck, farm-fresh produce, fruit and vegetables, sweet potato and local Wisconsin cheese, duck, chicken meal, chicken, menhaden fish meal, lamb, dried whole egg, beef pork meat meal, chicken fat, pork fat, salmon oil, flaxseed, omega fatty acids, oatmeal, pearled barley, lentil, brown rice, essential vitamins and minerals, dried tomato pomace (a mixture of tomato skins, pulp, and crushed seeds), celery, lettuce, and carrots, and alfalfa meal among others

Popular flavors

  • Salmon A-la Veg
  • Shredded beef in Gravy
  • Salmon tuna pate
  • Chicken duck pate

Acana

Acana combines real, natural ingredients to form flavours and recipes. Some of their common ingredients include:

Lamb, Duck, Apple, Pear, Pork, Squash, Mackerel, eggs, wild-caught fish, fruits and vegetables, pumpkin, red meat, poultry among others.

Popular flavors

  • Duck, turkey, and quail
  • Chicken, turkey and wild-caught fish
  • Turkey and kentucky greens
  • Pork and butternut Squash

Check out the current Acana recipes and Fromm recipes here.

🏡 About Acana and Fromm

Fromm Information

This brand has been existent for over a century! Fromm family pet food started in 1904 and has been handed down five generations after. Fromm is not just a brand but a legacy.

With a dry food plant in Wisconsin and a wet food plant in South Dakota, Fromm is reputed for producing personally formulated recipes.

Their high-quality ingredients are sourced from the US and prepared personally by current owner, Tom Nieman who inherited the business from his grandmother in 1983.

Fromm uses of natural and fresh ingredients to provide balanced and nutritious meals that would otherwise be fit for humans.

Acana Information

Owned by Champion PetFood, Acana remains one of the most popular and highly reputed brands in the Pet food industry.

Acana has its operations in the US and Canada.  Their pet food is produced in their sophisticated kitchens and they have three major values.

Their meals are meat-based, made with fresh, natural ingredients that are produced daily and never outsourced.

Farmers, fishermen and ranchers supply these ingredients for biologically appropriate meals.

Acana is a brand that has gained the confidence of pet owners over the years because their products deliver indisputable results.

🙀 Product Safety and Recalls through History

Companies make scheduled recalls on products that may have a foreseen defect or safety issues.

The importance of a recall is to conduct further safety tests in order to effect changes to product to ensure that it is safe for use.

Fromm Recalls

Fromm has been recalled once

  • March 14th, 2016 – Fromm recalled for incorrect vitamins and minerals.

Acana Recalls

Acana has never been recalled.

🏆 Acana Vs Fromm: And the winner goes to…

The winner for this review is Acana. While Fromm is almost as excellent in quality and promise, Acana provides more nutritious benefits.

Acana is also more highly reputed for product safety as it has never been recalled. It suffices to say Acana provides value for money.

If you want Then you should choose
Higher levels of protein Acana
A cost effective option Fromm
A wider variety of flavors and ingredients Fromm
Safety, based on number of recalls Acana
A balanced diet for all age levels both

References:

https://acana.com/

https://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/dog-food-reviews/acana-dog-food-dry/

https://frommfamily.com/

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *