Some pets can be quite choosy with meals! Especially when switching from one dietary formula to the other.
Sieving through hundreds of pet food brands out there in order to find the perfect meal for your pet can be a daunting task.
There are so many things to look out for especially since there is a ton of misinformation out there. However, the best brands are not far from your reach.
Let us compare two of the most popular and trusted pet food brands to get an idea of their nutritional value. This would give you an idea of what to look out for when purchasing the best cat and dog food for your pet.
Table of Contents
Taste of the wild vs Merrick FAQ
The concept of guaranteed analysis on pet food products is to assure purchasers of the precise nutrient content of each consumable. Emphasized by AAFCO, guaranteed analysis by food labels must meet certain requirements such as an exact value for the minimum percentage of crude protein and fat, as well as the maximum percentages of crude fiber and moisture on the basis of dry matter obtained. All of the percentages that I use in this comparison are averages of dry matter basis. Learn about dry matter basis here.
Merrick provides more protein than taste of the wild with a 5.36% difference on dry dog food as well as a 2.02% difference on wet cat food. However, both brands have a closed gap on wet dog food and dry cat food.
The Taste of the wild is significantly cheaper across all meal types, both wet and dry food.
The Merrick brand has 37 recipes for dry food and 65 for wet dog food while Taste of the wild only manages 9 recipes for dry dog food and 5 wet food.
The score remains more uneven with dog and cat treats as well as cat food. Merrick dominates with 13 dry food recipes for cats and 51 wet cat food recipes whereas Taste of the wild manages 2 recipes for both dry and wet cat food each.
Recalls on products, especially consumables, become necessary when there is a safety risk to consumers.
Taste of the wild as a brand has only been recalled once where as Merrick has had six recalls in history.
Taste of the wild and Merrick Pros and Cons
Taste of the wild Pros:
Taste of the wild Cons:
|Product (Dog Food)||Merrick||Taste of the Wild|
|Wet Food||65 recipes||5 recipes|
|Dry Food||37 recipes||9 recipes|
|Product (Cat Food)|
|Wet Food||51 recipes||2 recipes|
|Dry Food||13 recipes||2 recipes|
It can be observed that the Merrick brand has a wide variety of pet food types for both cats and dogs compared to Taste of the wild.
Taste of the wild vs Merrick Dog and Cat food
Dog Food Nutritional Value Comparison
|Merrick||Protein(wet)||Protein(dry)||Fat (wet)||Fat(dry)||Fiber (wet)||Fiber (dry)|
|Taste of the wild|
Both Taste of the wild and Merrick brand are recognized for high-quality pet food and exceptional taste. Each brand owns its unique flavor and secret ingredients that makes every chunk a burst of flavor for your pet.
Nutritional values are paramount to any aesthetic and these are represented in form of guaranteed analysis, stressed by the AAFCO. How do both brands compare to each other on the grounds nutritional value? Let’s take
Typically, proteins are an essential part of a dog’s diet as they require the functions of amino acids for development and metabolism.
Some amino acids can be synthesized by the body while some of them need to be taken regularly. Both pet food brands take these qualities into consideration by providing most competitive standard and roughly similar amounts of protein across all food types.
Like all carnivores, dogs and cats mostly thrive on meat and have a digestive system well suited for the consumption of animal protein.
For this reason pet foods are largely made of protein of the highest quality in order to give your pet the maximum amount of protein content it needs to
dietary fat, like proteins, plays an essential role in the overall health of pets. Their functions include but not limited to mitigation of infection, boosting immune system absorption and digestion of vitamins. There are slight differences in fat content between both brands.
Taste of the wild leads with 3.07% for dog food, whereas Merrick makes up for it in wet cat food.
Fiber Content Fiber content is fairly the same for the taste of the wild and Merrick brand. However, taste of the wild proves to be 2.41% more fibrous for wet cat food.
Dog and Cat Food Price Comparison
Prices for dog and cat foods are not the easiest things to keep track of, especially with the varieties and various dealers in the market.
However, there is an easy way to find an average price for pet food and that is the calculation of price per pound (lb) or per calorie (kcal).
|Dog Food||Merrick (dry)||Merrick (wet)||TOTW (dry)||TOTW (wet)|
|Cat Food||Merrick (dry)||Merrick (wet)||TOTW (dry)||TOTW (wet)|
The cost per pound is measured as the nutrient content plus moisture. The presence of moisture makes the cost-per-lb a less accurate metric compared to cost-per-kcal which is mostly based on dry content.
What flavors are available for Dog and Cat food?
Taste of the wild
The unique flavors of Taste of the wild are what sets this brand apart from all other pet food brand. every chunk is a delight for pets and formulated to improve health and immune system.
The ingredients for Taste of the wild includes but not limited to roasted Venison, smoked trout, wild boar, Lamb, Bison, sweet potatoes, roasted duck, Angus beef, chicken, blue berries, Ocean fish meal, Natural flavors, egg products, peas, tomatoes, canola oil, vitamins and minerals. All present in the right proportions to ensure a healthy diet and a happy meal for your pet.
Merrick comes with a wide variety of flavor so there is something for even the pickiest pets. Does your pet dislike rabbit recipes? Try the lamb and sweet potatoes, what about the texas beef? Heard of the salmon and potatoes?what’s the fuss about duck and sweet potatoes?
there is so much to look forward to with Merrick’s healthy grain-free meals.
About the Taste of the wild and Merrick
Taste of the wild Information
The taste of the wild adopts simple ingredients based on the natural cravings and biological uniqueness of dogs and cats. The brand also contains prebiotics used to improve the immune system and digestive tract of your pet.
Taste of the wild is a US based brand with branches in California, Arkansas, Missouri and other regions. Its flavors are well suited to both large and small dogs.
The Merrick pet food brand was founded in 1988 by the pet lover Garth Merrick, in Texas and was largely a family business.
The business expanded inevitably as new innovations of nutritious pet food formulas hit the market, giving pet owner numerous alternatives to ensure the health and development of their pets.
Product Safety and Recalls through History
Companies make scheduled recalls on products that may have a foreseen defect or safety issues. The importance of a recall is to conduct further safety tests in order to effect changes to product to ensure that it is safe for use.
Recalled six times for the following reasons
- May 23rd, 2018 – high levels of beef thyroid hormone
- Aug 8th, 2011 – salmonella risk
- Jan 28th, 2011 – Salmonella risk
- Aug 13th, 2010 – salmonella risk
- Aug 3rd, 2010 – salmonella risk
- July 2nd, 2010 – salmonella risk
Taste of the wild Recalls
- May 5th, 2012 – salmonella risk
Taste of the wild Vs Merrick
And the winner goes to…
It’s been a tough competition with Merrick leading in protein content whereas Taste of the wild stands out as the cheaper brand.
Merrick has a lot more flavors that Taste of the wild but unfortunately it also has more recalls in history till date. We can call this a tie! Both are great brands and offer the best nutritional values for dogs and cats alike.